NMSU: Garage Sales: Cash Not Trash
NMSU branding

Garage Sales: Cash, Not Trash

Guide G-106
Susan Wright, Extension Consumer Education Specialist
College of Agriculture, Consumer and Environmental Sciences New Mexico State University

If your home is bursting at the seams with littleused possessions, but you hate to think of throwing or giving them away, a garage sale could be the answer. A garage sale is a chance to clean out the garage and closets, and earn some cash at the same time. But don’t fool yourself that this is an easy project. People who profit from garage sales work hard for every cent they earn.

Are You Strong Enough?

Before you start piling your slightly used but still good items on your lawn or throw open the garage door and shout, “Sale!” you should consider whether you are the kind of person who can handle a sale. Are you physically strong enough to lift and carry all those clothes, toys, books, and appliances? Can you convince family members to part with their treasures?

Are you persuasive enough to convince your family to participate in the work? Can you deal with crowds of people swarming over your property and making less-than-complimentary remarks about the merchandise? If you thrive on hard work and a challenge and aren’t too sensitive to people’s comments, you can probably handle a garage sale.

If your major obstacle to a garage sale is lack of physical strength or a physical disability, consider asking a friend to share the heavy work and the profits. If you involve another person, or have a multifamily sale, make sure everyone agrees in advance on the division of labor and profits. Too often one person does all the work and everyone shares in the proceeds equally. Don’t let this happen to you.

The Right Place

Another question to ask yourself is, “Do I have a good location for a sale?” Ideal locations are in centrally located neighborhoods in town. Shoppers should be able to find your place on a city map.

If you live 50 miles from the next ranch, you can’t expect the kind of crowds that spell success. On the other hand, even if you live in a busy apartment complex, you may not be allowed by management to have a sale in the parking lot.

Once again, a friend or friends could be the answer. Their home may be better suited, so a multi-family sale away from your home could work for everyone.

Even if you have the biggest garage or driveway in town, your location may not be ideal if the neighbors complain. You may want to check with the next-door neighbors to make sure they won’t object. At the least, a garage sale causes parking problems and noise, but many times neighbors won’t mind and may even come over to see what’s for sale.

Know the Law

Check for special ordinances governing garage sales. Can you put signs up in the street? Do you need a permit for a sale? Are there regulations about hours for the sale? In some areas the number of garage sales you can have in a year is set—be sure to check if you plan to have more than one!

The Right Stuff

If you’re up to your ears in priceless antiques, a garage sale is not the best place to sell them. Big items, such as that 1979 like-new station wagon, are best sold other ways. But if you have old dishes, toys, small appliances, clothes, games, sports equipment, and books, you probably have the right stuff. If in doubt about the value of an item, get an appraisal or put it aside until you have time to check on it. With jewelry, use a magnifying glass and look for a karat or sterling mark before you put it in the sale box.

Timing Your Sale

The best time to have a sale is spring through fall. Bad weather can keep people at home in winter. Finally, consider the weather. Do you need an alternate plan if it rains?

Weekends are better than weekdays for a sale, with the exception of Fridays. Fridays are popular sale days in many communities. Two-day sales can be attractive if you have lots of merchandise to sell.

Dedicated garage sale shoppers get up early, so expect the biggest crowds at 8 a.m. or even earlier. Afternoons seem to drag at garage sales, so consider an 8 a.m. to noon sale on Friday and Saturday, for instance. Sundays are generally poor days for sales.

Just after payday is a shrewd time for a sale, and just before college or public school classes begin in the fall is also a time when buyers are looking for bargains.

Some people like to use gimmicks such as a surprise grab bag for a quarter. Consider letting your children sell their own things and keep the money.

Early Birds

Decide in advance what to do about early birds. It’s up to you whether to let them shop early or not. There are two schools of thought on this. The sticklers say opening time should be advertised and everyone should abide by it. Others say an early buyer is a serious buyer.

If someone comes asking to see a specific item you have advertised, he or she could be the only person interested in that item all day. Saying no, especially, if it is a big item, could mean no sale. But if early birds ask to see everything at the sale ahead of time, you might want to refuse. The important thing is to be prepared. Expect secondhand shop owners to arrive early, looking for items they can resell.

Be a Step Ahead

Be an early bird yourself on the day of your sale. Two ladies holding their first garage sale advertised their sale for 8 a.m. They were so busy with early customers, they didn’t get a chance to move some sale items out of the house until 11 a.m. “We were surprised! We weren’t expecting it,” they admitted.

Don’t underestimate the amount of time it will take to set up the sale. Do as much the night before as you can and have everything ready to set out just before the sale begins.

Don’t try to handle a garage sale alone. You will be overwhelmed at times answering questions and taking money. In general, the more people who are available to help you, the better. Be sure each knows his job.

Stock the refrigerator in advance with refreshments for everyone helping at the sale. A typical sale has busy times and lulls. Have a book, radio, or checkerboard on hand (marked “Not For Sale”) for idle moments.

Don’t try to be your own baby-sitter and run a sale at the same time. If necessary, have a baby-sitter for your small children.

Pricing Items and Handling Money

Price everything or at least know that all men’s pants, for instance, are the same price. Proper pricing methods can make the difference between a wellordered sale and chaos. If prices are set, you won’t have to make spur-of-the-moment pricing decisions during the rush of the sale. Use a marker of unusual color so prices can’t be changed.

Attend other garage sales to get an idea of what to charge. You don’t want to be out of line from the norm. Be honest: price a broken toaster lower than a like-new one, and if an item is broken, say so on the price tag.

Many people have found that masking tape or peel-off stickers work well for most items from clothing to appliances, or staple prices to items when possible.

If you are having a multi-family sale, you can use different-colored price stickers. When someone buys an item, peel off the sticker and put it on a sheet of notebook paper designated for that family. Be sure to indicate if the price was changed. At the end of the sale, stickers should reflect the sales made by each family. Make sure everyone understands the system ahead of time.

Some shoppers will try to barter. Before the sale begins, you should decide whether you will take less than the marked prices. You may want to stick to your prices the first two hours or so of the sale, and then come down a little when traffic thins.

It’s a good idea never to price items below a quarter. You can group small items so they total at least a quarter; that way it is easy to make change.

Get a cash box with a lid. Don’t carry money on your person. Never Leave the Cash Box Unattended. As the day progresses, don’t let the money build up in the cash box. Take proceeds into the house and keep only $30–$40 in the box. You can improvise a cash box from a shoe box, cigar box, or tackle box if necessary. Have a calculator, pencils, scratch pad, and record-keeping materials on hand.

Do not leave your house unlocked during a garage sale unless a friend or family member is inside at all times.

Spread the Word

OK, so you are strong enough, your family and friends will participate, you have a great location, and an amazing assortment of items. You have chosen a date and checked out city ordinances. Now you need to advertise.

Local newspapers’ classified advertising sections are the best places to tell people you’ll be open for business. Don’t just advertise in your daily newspaper; place ads in the weekly newspapers and shoppers that serve your town. Check newspaper deadlines for taking ads so you are sure to get your ad there on time.

If your house is hard to find, include directions in the ad. Don’t put your phone number in the ad unless you are willing to answer many phone calls. Be prepared for callers who want to come for a preview.

Write a catchy ad, but not one that is too cute. Tell people what kinds of items you have, and be sure to give them the dates, times, and place for the sale.

An ad might read: “Follow the signs to 225 Yucca (corner of Payne) July 11 and 12 for the sale you’ve been waiting for. Like-new toys, baby clothes, linens, books, fishing and ski equipment, crutches, plus much more, reasonable prices. 8 a.m. to noon both days.”

If you live in a community which has no local paper or shopper, you will need to post flyers with permission, of course, in supermarkets, coffee shops, churches, laundromats—any place with a bulletin board in your community.

On the day of the sale put up signs, too, pointing toward your house from main streets in town. Make the signs colorful, and put your address on them in big letters and numbers.

Radio stations will sometimes run a public service announcement the day of your sale. Ask them.

Word of mouth helps, too. Announce your sale to friends and if permissible, at meetings of organizations to which you belong. Many people love garage sales and will be eager to come to yours. Don’t neglect to tell them about it.

Prepare Yourself

Sale items won’t organize themselves into categories. You can expect to spend several days preparing for the sale. Enlist your family’s help.

Arrange to borrow card tables to display items, if needed. You will need a clothesline or racks for clothing and probably extra hangers. Hanging clothes keeps items from being unfolded and jumbled in a pile.

It’s useful for shoppers if items are grouped. Place children’s clothes or toys together for instance, and kitchenware in another area. Boxes keep small items from getting lost among other things.

Allow plenty of space for people to move about and browse. Crowding causes confusion. Arrange for electrical outlets or an extension cord to be available so appliances can be tested.

If you have quite a bit of clothing, you might consider partitioning off a corner of your garage for people to try on clothes. Provide a mirror. Do not allow them to enter your house.

Mark items in your garage or yard that are not for sale. If necessary, cover these items with sheets, drop cloths, or tarpaulins. Move small items to your back yard or into the house.

You can hang items on a fence or place them along your driveway. Put books, binding up, in cardboard boxes. If you or a friend have a knack for displaying items, use it to your advantage.

If you have toys for sale, put them in a box on the ground for children to play with. This keeps children busy and also helps sell the toys. Some people pick up toys at other sales to have on hand to keep children occupied. Be sure they are priced.

Up Front

Sit at the front of your property with the cash box so people will have to walk past you to leave. This will prevent thefts. Have helpers watch so items don’t walk off. Place items such as jewelry near the cashier or on the cashier’s table.

Indicate boundaries that are off limits to your customers. Use ropes or signs if your sales location is such that people might wander into your backyard or house.

If you can provide paper bags or boxes for purchases, people will appreciate it.

Add Pizzazz

Some experienced sellers like to add a little flair or some traffic-stopping touches such as balloons or streamers at the site. One couple hung an oversized pair of red hunter’s pants on a tree. Election hats, barbecue aprons, or other apparel can be worn to identify yourself and your assistants as the persons in charge.

A large half-price sign can be put up when sales lag and you are ready to clear out the last items. Most experts agree serving refreshments is far more trouble than it is worth. Children might have fun with a lemonade stand if you can cope with that and the sale, too.


Do not expect to sell everything. You will have some left-over items. You can give them to a charity or to friends, keep them, or throw them away. Some charitable organizations will pick up your leftover items and give you a receipt so you can claim a tax deduction.

It will take some time to clean up the lawn, patio, driveway, and garage and pack up everything. You may want to arrange in advance for extra help with this job.

Be sure to take the signs down when the sale is over. Some communities fine people who do not remove their garage sale signs promptly.

Then it is time to perform the most enjoyable task of the day—counting your profits.


Goss, Dottie, “Advanced Preparation is Key to Successful Garage Sale,” Minnesota Agricultural Extension Service.

Popp, Rita, “Garage Sale,” Las Cruces Sun-News, May 2, 1982, Las Cruces. NM.

“Pre-Planning A Garage Sale,” United Van Lines, #1, United Drive, Fenton, MO.

Special appreciation goes to Mrs. Jonee Gilliland for the material adapted from her program at Extension College Days, New Mexico State University, June 1984.

Original authors: Rita Popp, former Extension Media Specialist, and Jackie Martin, Extension Family Finance Specialist Emerita

To find more resources for your business, home, or family, visit the College of Agricultural, Consumer and Environmental Sciences on the World Wide Web at aces.nmsu.edu.

Contents of publications may be freely reproduced for educational purposes. All other rights reserved. For permission to use publications for other purposes, contact pubs@nmsu.edu or the authors listed on the publication.

New Mexico State University is an equal opportunity/affirmative action employer and educator. NMSU and the U.S. Department of Agriculture cooperating.

Revised and electronically distributed September 2002, Las Cruces, NM.